Friday, 17 June 2016

Chapter 36: Village Churches vs. the Urban MegaChurch

When I moved to Sydney in 1989, I found hundreds of city churches immersed in a huge metropolis, crammed into small, concreted plots of land on busy highways, with pocket handkerchief gardens, and plagued by constant traffic noise. This horrified me. Sydney's urban churches were unlike the other Australian churches I had attended. Where I grew up, churches were oases of peace, set well back from noisy main roads, and shielded by carefully tended gardens. The parishioners knew each other well, and lived in spacious ground floor houses, or on farms. Parishioners who lived in a country town or regional centre generally walked to their local church: only farmers drove to town for Sunday worship.

The Churches of megametropolis Sydney were further apart from each other, and urban community ties and common courtesy also seemed to be falling apart. On buses and trains, people eyed each other suspiciously, and didn't talk with strangers. Many failed churches had been deconsecrated, sold and converted into restaurants or homes. When I saw how crowded the city was, I assumed that its urban churches, surrounded as they were by traffic and high rises, would have left the village model of church far behind. They obviously needed technology to communicate with the crowded city population. But many of the churches I explored were still operating on the “safe and friendly village” model, which doesn't work in crowded, depersonalised cities. As a result, they were poorly attended by elderly parishioners, who were suspicious of outsiders and focused on maintaining fortress churches. Their querulous resistance to change, and their insistent demands that past traditions must be restored, told me that future shock had stopped these communities in their tracks. Elderly house owners mourned the loss of friendly urban streets and corner shops, and complained about the disturbing influx of inconsiderate refugees, immigrant workers, and unemployed jobseekers, who lived in high rise apartments.

Since I arrived, Sydney churches have separated into two distinct groups - traditional church communities, and progressive reformed churches who embrace technology. Pastoral care of parishioners is often outsourced to secular providers or religious retreat houses who cater for niche markets. Popular contemporary megachurches have ditched tradition, embraced the future, and grown into globalised corporate churches. They provide adult education, recreational clubs and social venues, and confidently promise health and wealth to tithing disciples. But many traditional churches have also survived by gathering bequests, assisting migrants, building global networks, and founding lucrative globalised businesses that promote and sell traditional music, books, customs, dress and liturgies. Churches who refuse to adapt, have closed, or have been absorbed into amalgamated collectives. Frequent clergy re-appointments, and increasing lay management of parishes, have replaced long term clergy residences. Either way,  survivor churches have found that attracting young families, and providing culturally appropriate activities, attractive products and community services as well as worship, is essential to managing a thriving city church.

Monday, 22 February 2016

Chapter 35: Lopsided Women’s Ministries = Lopsided Churches?

Judging from many responses to my last blog post, Anglican women's ministry in the Sydney Anglican Diocese is growing. Archbishop Glenn Davies has opened a door to asymmetrical female Anglican ministry, with an intriguing new theology of women's ministry. Archbishop Davies maintains that this new theology of Anglican female ministry is based on divinely accredited assymetric order, not on failed assumptions of patriarchal hierarchy. This distinction is untested, nor has it been proven to be effective.

Unbalanced lopsidedness (asymmetry) in Christian ministry is something that never crossed my mind until I read Archbishop Glenn Davies' recent advocacy for asymmetrical women's ministry. Silly me! I always imagined that Anglican ministry of all kinds is firmly grounded in a balanced relationship with the Holy Trinity, combined with balanced Christian human relationships that are equal under God, as mandated by the founder of Christianity.

So how is a trained, diaconally ordained Sydney Anglican woman expected to carry out her non-hierarchical, but assymertically ordered, supposedly Christian ministry, lopsidedly, in Sydney and beyond? Lopsidedness in ministry sounds like a difficult act to maintain. But we may have nothing at all to worry about. Sydney Anglican women ministers are overseen by an army of thoughtful asymmetrical male ministers who ensure that women deacons and their lay female assistants carry the lopsided weight of their ministerial tasks, while their male colleagues make all the decisions and get all the glory.

But I forget - Sydney already has a well recognised female role model for asymmetrical Anglican women's ministry. The Rev. Lucille Piper, an ordained Anglican priest who has willingly served as a Deacon in the Sydney Anglican Diocese, is also a respected missionary in Papua New Guinea. This saintly Anglican woman priest will, in all likelihood, be disrespectfully dubbed "Lopsided Lu" by the AAAWM (Archepiscopal Advocate for Asymmetical Women's Ministry)! But perhaps she will sensibly flee Sydney, before Archbishop Davies’ misogynistic displeasure descends on her.

The Rev. Lucille Piper: Prophet, Preacher, Missionary and Priest.

Anglican minister Rev. Lucille Piper OAM, known to her friends as Lu, is an outstanding witness for Christ in Australia, and beyond, as a missionary in Papua New Guinea. She has had a wonderfully varied church ministry. Finding herself faced with constantly changing circumstances, she did not hesitate to adapt her ministry flexibly to whatever God and her church communities required of her. 

After becoming a teacher, and being awarded a BA Honours from the University of New England in 1977, Lu went on missionary service in Papua New Guinea during 1968-73 and 1978-81. She served as an Anglican Church Army Officer in the Mosman area during 1984-90. This was followed by study leave and the award of a Bachelor of Divinity from Melbourne College of Divinity in 1994. Lu was deaconed in the Sydney Anglican Diocese in 1991, and priested in the Newcastle Anglican Diocese in 1995, From 1995-2004 Lu ministered at Stroud in the Hunter Valley of New South Wales. She returned to church missionary service in Papua New Guinea in 2004-2012. 

Lu's valuable contribution of nearly 20 years service in Papua New Guinea was recognised when she was awarded the Order of Australia Medal. After her return to Australia in 2012, Lu was appointed Assistant Minister at St Luke's Anglican Church, Mosman, where she ministered for several years before retiring from that parish and applying for a general licence to minister and preach in the Sydney Anglican Diocese. She is still awaiting the Diocese's response to her application.

In 2013 Lu was elected Convenor of the Sydney Branch of the Movement for the Ordination of Women, where she meets regularly with young and mature committed Anglican women engaged in Anglican church ministry all over Sydney. In January 2016 Lu returned briefly to Papua New Guinea to oversee the completion of church building works there. She will soon be returning to Sydney. 

Lu is much loved and admired by all who meet and know her. Please support her valuable, outstanding Anglican church ministry, and include her in your prayers.

Sunday, 21 February 2016

Chapter 34: Paige Katay’s Go Girl Ministry in the Sydney Anglican Diocese


The Sydney Anglican worm has turned! Paige Katay's brave defence of women's ministry in Sydney Anglican churches has overturned the corrupt merchants' tables in God's Temple. On the 18th February 2016, Paige Katay, a Meriden College student, proclaimed that the Bible is not sexist, and that Archbishop Glenn Davies has never said anything that restricts women's ministry in Sydney Anglican churches. Bravo, Paige! Paige has bucked the misogynist Sydney Anglican system: she has persuaded us that God wants women to be ordained as Anglican women priests to minister in the Sydney Anglican Diocese. 

Women priests have arrived, and they're staying. Via Paige, God has declared "GO GIRL!", revealed that the Bible imposes no limitations on women's ministry, and has ordained brilliant women preachers to serve the Sydney Anglican Diocese. Many Anglican women preach in Sydney, and their reasonable, inspired teaching and preaching, like Paige's teaching and preaching, is attentively heard. Last Sunday (21/2/2016) I witnessed a brilliant team of Sydney Anglican women lead the worship at St Barnabas' Church Broadway. Many women exercise powerful Christian leadership and management in Sydney Anglican churches, and the vast majority of Sydney Anglican men respect and defer to them, just as all Sydney Anglicans defer to Paige's reasonable judgement and proclamation. 

It is certainly a fact that Sydney Anglican parishes could not function without their current women leaders, administrators and managers. In fact, gender discrimination against women's priestly ministry in all its forms has fallen flat on it's face in the Sydney Anglican Diocese since journalists revealed how prejudiced churchmen exposed church women to domestic violence by endorsing rampant male misogyny. Ordained Anglican women priests from outside Sydney visit many Sydney parishes regularly, and Holy Communion has been celebrated by an Anglican woman priest (a senior Australian Defence Force military chaplain) in Sydney, without the heavens falling in. Sydney Anglican discriminative male dogmatism has collapsed in shame at its excessive hubris. The army of offensive Sydney Anglican male misogynists who invaded Sydney Anglican churches and dominated them for many years are definitely on the way out. However, they're kicking and screaming all the way down the nave to the church door. The Sydney Anglican Synod is still dominated by men who disagree violently with Paige. Their latest coward punch is to use indoctrinated, clearly good-hearted, but confused babes in arms as human shields.

Scared out of their wits by being consigned to misogynist hell and damnation by the community at large, these Sydney Anglican churchmen scrambled to rewrite their anti-women-priest dogmas. Rapidly backing away from their insistence on exclusively male church headship coupled with righteous male subordination of church women, they (and a cohort of well rewarded, subordained female deacons who have signed away their right to female priesthood) are now teaching two convoluted, unattractive red herring heresies about women's ministry that distract and confuse parishioners.

Complementarianism - otherwise known as Plugging the Gaps Ministry

Ironically, Sydney Anglican mob bosses couldn't find a word in the Oxford English Dictionary to describe it, so they invented a new buzzword - complementarianism. This convenient invention illogically asserts that trained and subordained women ministers, however capable, should do only what male ministers can't do, or don't want to do. Women get the ministry crumbs that fall under the table, the leftovers, and are supposed to lick them up gratefully. Like cleaning the church. It's so completely in tune with Vatican male misogyny that even Pope Francis is promoting it!

Egalitarianism - otherwise known as KISS (Keep It Simple Stupid) Ministry

This heresy involves replacing the word "equal" with "egalitarian", in order to control discourse about women's ministry. "Egalitarianism" is reductive, but the equality of women with men under God, preached by Jesus Christ, raises us all up to enjoy the riches of God's glory together. Egalitarian churches are anti-equality: the egalitarian church system reduces ministry to a lowest common denominator, promotes pseudo-ministry TAFE level adult education courses, and denigrates tertiary education in Christianity, reserving it for senior males. Egalitarian churches claim to honour women's ministry, while avoiding the issue of women ministers' equality with male ministers under God, and the right of women to be ordained to sacramental priestly ministry. Celebration of Holy Communion (Eucharist) is minimised and sometimes abandoned in egalitarian churches. Overworked, undereducated male and female Deacons carry out a greatly simplified public egalitarian ministry, while a selected caste of ordained male priests avoid the limelight, celebrate Holy Communion privately and regularly, and reserve all power to themselves and their selected, well paid, silent lay allies. This is the same system used by the Pharisees in Jesus' time on earth. Jesus condemned the Pharisees for parading themselves as holy and sinless, while condemning others to perpetual servitude.


Tuesday, 5 May 2015

Chapter 33: Documenting Australian Women’s Church Ministries

I began this blog to record my Church ministry saga, and those of other Australian church women, and found myself embroiled in church controversies about the role and extent of church women's ministries in Australia.  These distracting spats take attention away from where it should be - on the laudable achievements of the many past and present women ministers of the Australian Church, such as Abbess Benedicta Phillips, Elizabeth Fry, Catherine Chisholm, and currently, Dominican Sister Trish Madigan and Anglican hymn writer Rev. Elizabeth Smith of Western Australia, now ministering in the outback city of Kalgoorlie. 


The stories of many great Australian Church women ministers, and the way they've shaped the worship, mission and work of Australian churches, are not well known or publicised. Australian Church men are encouraged and assisted by their male church sponsors to blow their ministry trumpets loudly, and they do so, but Church women often sink into oblivion because they have not bothered to record or document what they and their ministry sisters do. No matter how maddening or hilarious women's church ministry experiences are, they make wonderful journalistic press when well researched and well told. Consider, for instance, the ministry story of Daisy Bates, Kabbarli, the great but maligned Christian missionary to the Aborigines, recognised as a saint in her time by indigenous and settler Australians, and well documented, but consigned to grudging token recognition in church histories written by men. The history of church women's ministries should not consist of an obituary list of under-recorded names and dates. One way of informing the public about church women's ministry is to provide online links to their stories via social media like Blogger, Facebook, Twitter, Google+ and Pinterest. More and more church women are doing this: if every church woman posted one story about past or current female church ministry per week, it would focus greater media attention on the achievements and value of church women's ministry. Recently I published a Pinterest Board on women ministers, and another on women church musicians, and many people reposted my links - much information is already on the Internet, so why not make it better known? 


Lots of Australian girls and women work as unofficial ministry volunteers in Australian churches, but few are paid or even acknowledged. Even in denominations ordaining women, the percentage of Church women whose names and work are praised and accurately recorded in church bulletins, archives and histories us lamentably low. Yet Australian churches would close without their female workers. And time after time on the Internet I've received reports of church women being undervalued by male clergy, exploited, bossed around as if they were children, actively denigrated, and denied full liturgical roles, commissioning and recognition. 


Well, now we have a remedy. Don't wait for your clergy to document your church ministry - do it yourself, online. You'll be surprised at the breadth and quality of your ministry achievements. Take the recalcitrant Australian Church bull by the horns and guide it gently into the waters of eternal life - the fruitful and flourishing ministries of Australian Church women.

Chapter 32: Pink Smoke over Sydney II - Egalitarianism Hits the Fan

Foreseeing an outraged female reaction to his dogmatic complementarian stance, Archbishop Glenn Davies and his complementarian corps have staged a comical takeover coup, in the form of dogmatic "egalitarianism." Sydney Anglican "egalitarians" claim to be sympathetic to women's ministries, but they stop short at priestly ordination for women. Sydney Anglican "egalitarian" dogma proposes reducing church ministry to a lowest common denominator by discarding both Holy Communion and all forms of clerical ordination. Sydney Anglicans are now required to choose between the complementarian camp, or the egalitarian camp, neither of which favour ordaining women priests, who were supposedly outlawed by the overwhelmingly male Sydney Anglican General Synod.

In late April 2015 Archbishop Glenn Davies showed his true colours by withdrawing preaching licenses from several ordained Sydney women deacons. However these women are still preaching, because their diaconal ordination obliges them to ignore this complentarian / egalitarian dogma.


Chapter 31: Pink Smoke over Sydney


Anglican Women Priests defy Sydney Ministry ban!


Guess what. It's a complete myth that there are no Anglican women priests in the Sydney Anglican Diocese. Women priests are here, and they're staying. It's a complete myth that women don't preach in the Sydney Anglican Diocese. They do, and their insistent, reasonable voices are heard. And it's a complete myth that only church men exercise Christian leadership and management in Sydney Anglican churches. Sydney Anglican parishes could not function without their current women leaders and managers. Discrimination against women priests in Sydney Anglican churches has fallen flat on it's face since journalists revealed how prejudiced churchmen have exposed church women to domestic violence by endorsing rampant male misogyny. Anglican women priests from outside Sydney visit Sydney parishes regularly, and Holy Communion has been celebrated by an Anglican woman priest (a senior Australian Defence Force military chaplain) in Sydney, without the heavens falling in. Sydney Anglican dogmatism is in disarray. The Sydney misogynists who invaded our churches are definitely on the way out, but they're kicking and screaming all the way down the nave to the church door.

Scared out of their wits by being consigned to misogynist hell and damnation by the community at large, these Sydney Anglican churchmen have scrambled to rewrite their anti-women-priest dogmas. Rapidly backing away from their insistence on exclusively male church headship coupled with righteous male subordination of church women, they (and a gullible cohort of well rewarded, indoctrinated, subordained female deacons who have signed away their right to female priesthood) are now teaching a new, convoluted red herring heresy designed to distract and confuse parishioners. The largely irreligious Sydney public, many of whom have been driven out of the church by their bigotry, is just bemused by their stupidity.

Ironically, they couldn't find a word in the Oxford English Dictionary to describe it, so they invented a new buzzword - complementarianism. This convenient invention illogically asserts that trained and subordained women ministers, however capable, should do only what male ministers can't do, or don't want to do. Women get the ministry crumbs that fall under the table, the leftovers, and are supposed to lick them up gratefully. Like cleaning the church. It's so completely in tune with Vatican male misogyny that even Pope Francis is promoting it!

Wednesday, 7 January 2015

Chapter 30: ANZAC Day 2015 - recolonisation ofdecolonized Australia?


As we celebrate ANZAC Day 2015 we recall past sacrifices in past wars, pray for a positive outcome of current conflicts, and remember soldiers serving today. In the emotion of personal remembrance, questions about whether wars are just, or not, tend to fade into the background. Yet today we are ever more painfully conscious of the difficulties of our troops serving in harm's way, and the post-war suffering of returned soldiers.  ANZAC Day is important because it not only brings us face to face with striking examples of heroic mateship, but also with the cold-blooded, mortal violence that is enacted in extended wars. Christian churches and chaplains have played an important pastoral role in wartime, not only as comforters, but often as moral and ethical arbiters consulted by governments. Yet in decolonised Australia, the ties between Church and State have noticeably diminished, along with the moral influence of the Churches over wartime decisions. Some Australians think that the only way to restore moral credibility to Australia in wartime, is to reconnect the country to Church systems by recolonising it. Is this possible or desirable?

Australian Churches are asking themselves why their moral authority has diminished, and what can be done to restore it. Right, wrong, justice, judgement and doomsday have been grist to Church mills for centuries. Sad to say, some Churches have misused their moral authority in the past to inspire extreme fear of God in order to extort  "indulgence" fees from guilt-ridden parishioners eager to buy God's favour (the sin of simony). Clerical corruption and abuse has caused many Australians to reject and abandon unrepentant churches. An unhealthy, grasping obsession with the splinters of other people's sins, while ignoring the proverbial log in the Church's own eye, has also cost Australian Churches dearly. Yet all Australian Christians (church attenders or not) know that discerning right from wrong in good conscience under God is an essential moral skill. Australians generally, Christian or not, can judge what is right and wrong in human society. They know that discerning how to remedy wrongs with good judgement guided by God involves much more than greed for personal salvation.

In the past, Churches allied with various governments filled an active role as the moral gatekeepers of European, Miiddle Eastern, African, American, Asian and colonial societies, In our decolonised time this is rarely the case. Western law was grounded in basic Christian moral codes (e.g. the Ten Commandments), so the colonial churches endorsed most civil and criminal legal judgements and penalties, and could reverse unjust decisions. When clergy delivered sermons, people listened carefully, because (despite the claim that Church and State were separate, with God as the higher power), clergy were invested with certain powers as officials of "the Establishment", i.e. the combined Church and State. In England, Scotland and Australia in the 1940s and 50s, church clergy, vestry members and office bearers had many government record keeping responsibilities. Some of these tasks still survive, but the Parish Roll is no longer a comprehensive Census, and licensed lay officials now perform many tasks formerly reserved to Christian clergy. Australians who enjoy nostalgic memories of "the good old days" would like to rewind the clocks back to the British Empire, but time marches us inexorably on into a globalised multicultural future.

So who, and how, in our multicultural Australian society where Church alliance with the State is tenuous, and multilingualism is a serious barrier to quick communication, do Australians determine what is right, what is wrong, what penalties will be imposed for which crimes and misdeanours, and how our community reacts when our government wants us to wage war on other peoples? Leaving moral decisions and laws to secularised, irreligious politicians and lawyers has produced an unwieldly, painfully slow legal system that obstructs justice, is only available to the affluent, and is slow to react to crises. Yet it is now possible for alert, responsible Australian Christians to exert a powerful influence on moral and political decisions through the Internet. At this time Australian Christians have a responsibility to remain aware of current legislation and social justice issues, and take concerted, calm, well considered peaceful action when necessary. Speaking up peacefully and clearly in the Australian media to reform inadequate laws, maintain humane moral standards, eliminate bullying and enforce justice for neglected victims has never been more important.